ACT Legislative Assembly Hansard

Advanced search

Next page . . Previous page . . . . Speeches . . . . Contents . . . . Sittings . . . . Search

Legislative Assembly for the ACT: 2011 Week 2 Hansard (10 March) . . Page.. 729..

But at the heart of the drive for bills of rights and charters of rights is a lack of trust in the legislature. It is effectively saying that if it is just left to the legislature and the processes we have inherited and refined over many hundreds of years, people's human rights will not be protected. Of course, it was that thinking, perhaps understandably, in the US context that led to their Bill of Rights being constitutionally enshrined. Anyone who has looked closely at the experience in the US would say that that has not been a success. Gun control is an obvious example where, in many cases, even a basic restraint of people's ability to carry weapons is deemed unconstitutional due to their Second Amendment rights, I think it is, to bear arms.

We have a different scenario here, but that gives some context as to where these things can eventually go and the dangers of a charter of rights or a bill of rights, and why many lawmakers, including many significant figures in the Labor Party, argue against them. In fact, the federal Labor government recently looked at this issue and appeared to in the end back away from it. Having had Father Frank Brennan look into this issue on their behalf, the federal Labor Party appears to have walked away from the issue, and with some justification.

There are a number of criticisms, and I will go into why we had concerns when the Human Rights Act was passed. The concerns are that the power is taken away from the legislature and that we eventually see a pitting of the human rights of one group or class of people against the rights of another group or class of people, and I will touch on some examples of that.

The other concern that we raise is that having a human rights act is the government's way of saying, "Well, we're human rights compliant because we've have got a human rights act,"even if they subsequently ignore that act and do not deliver human rights in many cases. I will touch on those various aspects.

In terms of the unintended consequences—perhaps the intended consequences for some people—of rights being pitted against common sense, we do not have to look too far to find examples. Of course, the most recent example here in the ACT was the issue at Lanyon high school. We have a very hard-working, diligent principal in Bill Thompson seeking to work with his community to work against truancy. Undertaking his legal obligations as principal, having responsibility for these students, one of the ways he wanted to work against truancy—certainly by no means the only way—was to stop kids hanging out in local shops. Some of the wagging kids would end up at the local shops, so he wanted to work with local shop owners to say, "Let's work together. Let's us not have kids hanging out. Let's not give them any more incentives than they would otherwise need to wag school. Let's work together to keep them in school". I think we would all agree that that is a very good aim from a principal. He was thinking laterally, and he got some agreement.

The initiative was reported at the time, and some businesses chose not to cooperate. That is their choice as business owners; no-one was being conscripted into such an arrangement. But many businesses joined the initiative. Then we had a response from the human rights commissioner, backed by the Labor Party and the Greens in this place, saying, "Well, this is against the Discrimination Act. This is potentially denying the right of a child or young person to shop at a store. They are being discriminated against on the basis of their age". Common sense tells us they are not

Next page . . Previous page. . . . Speeches . . . . Contents . . . . Sittings . . . . Search

If you have special accessibility requirements in accessing information on this website,
please contact the Assembly on (02) 6205 0439 or send an email
Accessibility | Copyright and Disclaimer Notice | Privacy Policy
© Legislative Assembly for the ACT